Safe Sleep: The AAP Wants Me to Do WHAT??!!

The AAP came out with new safe sleep guidelines which are carefully created based on statistics and expert input. The only problem is that babies often have their own opinion on how they’d like to sleep which often puts parents in the difficult position of balancing safety and sanity.

So I asked Amber from Pip & Grow if she would help make sense of it all. She is a child injury prevention expert with specialties in infant safe sleep and child passenger safety and she totally ‘gets’ how hard it is to implement sleep guidelines – no matter how safe they are.


In October 2016, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) released their updated recommendations for safe sleep. As an infant safe sleep expert at a children’s hospital, I’ve gotten a lot of questions about what the guidelines mean and how parents are supposed to apply them.


The gist hasn’t changed – baby alone, always on his or her back, and in a safe sleep space like a crib, bassinet, or bassinet box. However, there are some new recommendations that have parents scratching their heads.

To help, I’m breaking down the three most important guidelines. Let’s start with the most panic-inducing:


Room Sharing

AAP Recommendation: Room share—keep baby’s sleep area in the same room where you sleep for the first 6 months or, ideally, for the first year.

And parents everywhere cry into their (cold) coffee.

Upon reading this guideline, a wise friend said, “Why don’t they just give new moms a prescription for anti-depressants and the name of a divorce attorney on the way out of the hospital too??”


So why recommend it? The AAP wants us to do this because room sharing can reduce the risk of SIDS by as much as 50%. That’s huge. But for some (many?) families, one year just isn’t realistic. That’s ok. The key here is balance. You need to do what helps you be a sane, good parent. If that means room sharing for 4 months- then YAY! You room shared for four months!

Many parents also have practical issues with this one.

Most of us don’t have space in our bedroom for a full size crib – which is the AAPs dreamiest safe sleep space – but, a mini-crib, traditional bassinet, pack ‘n’ play, or bassinet box will do the trick. You know what’s right for your family.



Back to Sleep

AAP Recommendation: Until their first birthday, babies should sleep on their backs at all sleep times—for naps and at night.

This one is kind of confusing because, I don’t know about your kiddos, but mine started rolling over around 10 weeks. So one year??? Mkay.

BUT, the AAP does go on to clarify that once your baby becomes comfortable rolling from back to front and front to back, you do not have to return your baby to their back.

If your kiddo can’t roll over

Put him on his back always. This is so, so important. A lot of times I tell parents to do what’s right for them. In this case, that’s not true. Back-sleeping is crucial for safety. And make sure grandparents and baby sitters know, too. Grandma probably got the exact opposite advice when you were a mere babe.

If your kiddo can roll

You get a pass on this one. You don’t need to stand over him all night long anxiously turning him from belly to back. Use that time for other important stuff- like streaming your favorite show on Netflix while stuffing your face with ice cream.



Safer Bed Sharing

AAP Recommendation: An eversoslightnod to ‘safer’ bed sharing.


I know, that’s what I said too.

Thankfully, the AAP is acknowledging that we don’t parent in a perfect world. We have to do this job in real life and for some parents that includes bed-sharing.

I get asked ALL THE TIME about ways to safely bed share. Bad news first: There is no perfectly safe way to bed share. Now, good news: There are ways to make bed-sharing safer.

To make bed-sharing safer:

  • Plan ahead. Look at your sleeping situation in the (harsh) light of day and figure out what will make it safest for baby. Try to avoid deciding to bed-share for the first time in the middle of the night when none of us have our wits about us.
  • Keep your bedding to the bare minimum. Use a pillow for yourself and a blanket you will wrap around your body (keeping it away from baby). Nothing else needed.
  • Only bed-share one parent at a time. If baby’s in bed, send one parent to the guest room or couch for the night. (Think of it as a vacation?)
  • Sleep on a firm mattress. Nothing squishy like a couch, armchair, or waterbed (do people even have those anymore?).
  • Choose bed over a couch or chair. Studies show bed-sharing is riskiest if you sleep on the sofa or in a recliner. If you think you might fall asleep while feeding your baby – feed baby in bed.
  • Make bed-sharing for parents only. Bed-sharing with adults other than a parent has a higher risk of suffocation. (Why? Parents tend to be more aware of baby and sleep less deeply when baby is nearby.)
  • Quit smoking if you do smoke. Being exposed to smoke raises baby’s risk of SIDS.
  • Don’t take medicines or drugs that make you sleepy before you bed share.
  • Avoid alcohol before bed-sharing.

Bed-sharing is most risky if:

  • Your baby is less than 4 months old
  • Your baby was born premature or low birth weight
  • You smoked during pregnancy
  • You are excessively tired (Well who isn’t? You just had a baby.)

An important note – planning ahead is key. Like many other unplanned things (pregnancy anyone? *raises hand slowly*), not planning to bed-share can lead to riskier choices – like having too much bedding, sleeping on too soft a surface, or having more than one adult in bed with baby. So, if you think you might bring baby into bed – make a plan ahead of time.

The take home point of all of this? Do the best you can and give yourself some grace when you just can’t muster ‘the best.’

Be kind to yourselves parents – this is seriously hard work and you are doing an amazing job.


Our Next Recos:

Smitten Baby Box: Is the Simplest Way Actually the Best Way?

New Mom Kits: Diaper Station

Hair Today, Gone Tomorrow: The Truth About Postpartum Hair Loss


What’s a Bassinet Box?



Bassinet boxes are lightweight, portable safe sleep spaces with a much smaller footprint. Finland first introduced the bassinet box in the 1930s when they started giving boxes away to moms-to-be at prenatal visits and they now have one of the lowest infant mortality rates in the world.

Some parents worry about the bassinet box being made of cardboard – they think that means it’s “cheap” or low quality –  but the cardboard isn’t about price.

As it turns out, using cardboard is a safety choice. Cardboard is really good at reflecting carbon dioxide away from babies instead of absorbing it like a soft fabric might. Keeping carbon dioxide away helps reduce the risk of SIDS or suffocation. Who knew?

Cardboard also makes the bassinet both light and strong – the Smitten Sleep System, for example, weighs just 2lbs, but can hold up to 100lbs. Plus, bassinet boxes are considered a safe sleep space for baby’s first 6 months, which just so happens to cover the riskiest time for SIDS or suffocation.

Interested in trying a bassinet box?

Check out Pip & Grow to learn more, or to purchase one of these nifty alternatives to the traditional bassinet.

Topics:Baby, Sleep
Written By
More from Amber Kroeker

Safe Sleep: The AAP Wants Me to Do WHAT??!!

The AAP came out with new safe sleep guidelines which are carefully...
Read More

You May Also Like


  • No North American adult mattress is firm enough for an infant. The risk of SIDS increases 40x putting a baby in bed with you, not to mention the risk of Accidental Suffocation and Strangulation which is the biggest killer BY FAR of infants under 12 months. Alone, Back, Crib/bassinet is the safest possible way for baby to sleep. In-bed sleepers are NOT FLAT and NOT FIRM and have killed many infants in the past. Do not buy into the marketing hype. “Breathability” is not a thing. The $40 Walmart mattress that is certified is wayyyy safer than the $200 bed nest. I don’t know how the people who market these things live with themselves.

    I used to bed-share but stopped the second the statistics were pointed out to me with solid evidence. The AAP and CPS don’t say it out of some kind of conspiracy; they say it because they have access to all the information and studies.

  • What do you think about the snoo? It is the new bassinet that sense when your kid cries and rocks/shushes them. Is that safe?

    • I haven’t seen it in the flesh, but from everything I can see, it would check all the safety boxes. I think the biggest drag with it is just how darn expensive it is.

  • This article seems to really be promoting the practice of bringing baby to bed with you. If you read the new guidelines by the AAP, their stance, unchanged from before, is that baby’s own bed is the safest place for him/her. Over and over the AAP stresses that a crib or bassinet in the parent’s room is the safest place for baby. Your article is slanted in that it makes it sound as if all of a sudden, the AAP is on board with taking the baby to bed with you, which THEY ARE NOT. The reason that evidence shows room sharing decreases the risk of SIDS, is because parents are less likely to sleep in bed or on the couch (killer couches) with baby, if they share a room.

    • I didn’t get the impression that this article was slanted towards bed sharing, at all. In fact, it continues to communicate an anti-bed sharing stance, unfortunately. This fear mongering needs to stop! There are several approaches to parenting that carefully consider the physical and emotional well-being of the baby while ALSO considering the unique needs to the parent(s) of the child. There truly is no one way to parent and care for a child and, in my opinion, the very best gift we can give to our children is to tune in to their emotional needs as infants and meet them when we can.

    • Hi Stephanie!

      Great question. Currently, there are no U.S. standards for in-bed co-sleepers such as Snuggle Nest or Dock-a-tot. This means that there are no safety regulations that products such as these need to meet. Now, that doesn’t mean they are unsafe it just means no one is watching (meaning government or other agencies that regulate consumer products) when it comes to whether these products are safe or not.

      Things I like about in-bed sleepers? They allow parents a bit more peace of mind and perhaps a bit more safety than just having the kid in bed with them. It falls in line with that whole ‘planned bed sharing’ bit discussed above.

      What I don’t like about them? Many of the products are quite small and your baby will outgrow it quickly. Meaning that they do not have a safe sleep space after 3 or 4 months (unless you buy another larger product). Many of the products also have fluffy or foam walls which does not fall in line with American Academy of Pediatrics safe sleep recommendations.

      The idea of an in-bed sleeper is to give your baby their own protected sleep space while still keeping baby near. If you are searching for an in-bed sleeper, look for one with firm walls and with a tall enough wall height that the chance of getting a pillow or blanket over the wall is reduced. Also, look for one that will last your baby at least 6 months. After 6 months, the risk of SIDS and sleep death is greatly reduced.

      Every parent has to make a choice on what works well for them. Every parent wants to keep their child as safe as possible while staying as sane as possible. Great job parents!


      Amber Kroeker, MPH
      Founder and CEO
      Pip & Grow, LLC

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.